KABUL: The United Nations Assistance Mission for Afghanistan (UNAMA) recently released a report highlighting concerns regarding the state of human rights in the country. However, the Islamic Emirate, the de facto authority in Afghanistan, has denied the claims made in the report and criticized UNAMA for allegedly lacking accurate on-the-ground information.
Zabiullah Mujahid, the spokesperson for the Afghan caretaker government, expressed scepticism about the UNAMA report’s accuracy. Speaking to TOLOnews, he argued that the UN mission had failed to properly assess the ground realities in Afghanistan and had instead focused on what he considered to be less significant issues within the country. According to Mujahid, UNAMA has historically engaged in what he called “propaganda” and has not fulfilled its duty to effectively address and resolve problems in Afghanistan. He further asserted that the reports published by UNAMA do not align with the factual situation on the ground in Afghanistan.
UNAMA’s recent report, covering the period from July to September 2023, raised concerns about various human rights issues in Afghanistan. These concerns encompassed limitations on the rights of women and girls, the treatment of former government officials and members of the security forces, the conditions of detainees, instances of corporal punishment and the use of the death penalty, restrictions on Ashura celebrations, and the indiscriminate detention and imprisonment of human rights defenders and media workers.
READ ALSO: Hamas Releases Two More Hostages, US Demands Rest be Freed
While UNAMA has voiced these concerns, there have been opposing viewpoints within Afghanistan. Some individuals, like Zakiullah Muhammadi, a university lecturer, have called for the swift recognition of the Islamic Emirate and have expressed concerns that such reports could hinder the recognition process. On the other hand, political analyst Tariq Farhadi has emphasized the importance of UNAMA’s report on the human rights situation in Afghanistan, urging government officials not to deny its findings but to work on resolving the identified problems.
This dispute over the UNAMA report is not the first of its kind. In a previous report, the UN mission claimed to have recorded “800 cases of extrajudicial killings and torture, ill-treatment, indiscriminate detention, and disappearances.” These allegations were met with strong denials by the Islamic Emirate.
The debate surrounding the UNAMA report underscores the ongoing challenges in Afghanistan’s transition and the complexity of assessing the human rights situation amidst shifting political dynamics. As the international community grapples with recognizing the new government and addressing human rights concerns, dialogue and cooperation will be essential to finding common ground and working towards a more stable and rights-respecting Afghanistan.
